Offering Legal, Tax & Business Services to Investment Managers & Hedge Funds Worldwide Real Estate Hedge Funds
Real Estate Funds, Investing & Investee Funds For purposes of the Investment Company Act of 1940 (1940 Act), an investment company (hedge fund) is one that invests, reinvests, or trades in securities. To avoid classification as a hedge fund, a real estate fund should reply on one or more of the three statutory exclusions and one regulatory exemption that exist. Section 3(c)(1) of the 1940 Act excludes any private investment company has not more than 100 owners, taking into account the owners of all series and classes of its securities, whether debt or equity, voting or non voting in monitoring the 100 owner limit. The 1940 Act has look through rules that apply to an "investing fund" investing in an "investee fund" (i.e., a sub fund). The owners of the Investing Fund are counted as direct beneficial owners of the Investee Fund if the following both conditions are met: the investing fund is a Section 3(c)(1) or Section 3(c)(7) fund and the investing fund owns more than 10% of the investee fund's voting securities. If the investing fund's beneficial owner county pushes the investee fund's beneficial owners over the 100 person limit, the invest fund cannot rely on Section 3(c)(1). Sponsors should understand that limited partnership and limited liability company interest may constitute "voting securities" for purposes of the look-through test. To avoid registration under the 1940 Act, a real estate fund may have to limit an investing fund to less than 10% of its outstanding interests or count the investing fund's owners as its direct beneficial owners.
Mortgage Loans & Seconds The securities laws explicitly state that any “note” (i.e., debt instrument) is a security. If your fund were to instead make direct commercial mortgage loans to borrowers, it is likely that the such note (i.e. the loan) is not a security. A fund that has a portfolio of commercial mortgages purchased from a third party loan originator is in fact an investor securities. In that the fund is not an exempt real estate fund and you are subject to state regulation as an investment adviser.
Real Estate FundSection 3(c)(5) of the 1940 Act excludes a real estate program that is primarily engaged in purchasing or acquiring mortgages and other liens on, and interests in real estate. The SEC has blessed real estate programs (i.e., exempt from the 1940 Act) when at least 55% of the fund's assets consist of mortgages and other liens on or interests in real estate, and the remaining 45% of its assets consist primarily of real estate related investments. The SEC has agreed that the test that at least 45% of a program's asset consist "primarily of real estate-related investments" means that at least 55% of the 45% must be primarily in real estate related assets and the remaining assets may be investments entirely unrelated to real estate, such as stocks, U.S. government securities, commercial paper, etc. Fund sponsors should note that the test is an asset test and not an income test. The percentage tests relate to obtain SEC "no-action" relief. In many cases, a real estate fund with more than 50% but less than 55% of its assets invested in mortgages or real estate may be able to rely on Section 3(c)(5). Real estate programs that use financing subsidiaries may also be able to rely on Rule 3a-5 to avoid registration under the 1940 Act. Contact Us for Assistance
What is Real Estate?Real estate includes a fee interest, a leasehold, a note secured by a mortgage on real estate, and certificates in entire mortgage pools. Being a limited partner is a real estate partnership is not "real estate" for purpose of Section 3(c)(5). However, if you have the power to removed a partnership's general partner with or without case, then your investment is an investment is in real estate. If your real estate program invests in an entity that owns real estate assets, it must be a majority owned subsidiary to be counted as real estate. This means that your program owns 50% or more its voting interests. Generally interests or influence over management can be treated as voting interests. Even non voting interests can be considered the equivalent to voting interests if the holder has such economic interests so as to have "control" over management.
Qualified Purchasers Section 3(c)(7) of the 1940 Act excludes your fund as a real estate fund if all of its investors are qualified purchasers. Generally, that refers to an individual with $5,000,000 in investments, a family-operated company that owns at least $5,000,000 in investments, a trust not formed for the specific purpose of investing in the Section 3(c)(7) fund and of which each trustee who makes investment decisions on behalf of the trust and each contributor is a qualified purchaser, or a person, acting for such person's own account or the account of other qualified person's who owns or invests on a discretionary basis at least $25,000,000 in investments. A qualified purchaser also includes a company not meeting these requirements as long as all the beneficial owners of the company are qualified purchasers.
Real Estate Fund Managers & Investment Adviser Registration (RIA) Does your fund invest directly in real property (i.e., takes title to real estate). If yes, your fund is not investing in securities and it is a "real estate" fund. The same is true if your fund (or its delegate) controls and/or actively manages real estate. However, if your fund is a passive owner, the fund is invests in securities, it is not a real estate fund, and you as the fund manager are subject to investment adviser regulation. If your fund invests in stock of company that owns real property, then the fund is not a real estate fund and you as the fund manager are subject to investment adviser regulation (unless your fund owns 100% of the stock). If your fund invests in a limited partnership that owns real estate or invests as an investor in an entity that owns real property, your fund is not a real estate fund and you are subject to state investment adviser regulation.
Read leading, cutting-edge articles on hedge funds and taxes by Hannah Terhune, hedge fund and international tax attorney. Her articles are widely published on the Internet and recommended by TheStreet.com and other respected media.
Capital Management Services Group, Inc. is recognized by discriminating persons as being one of the foremost legal authorities in the hedge fund industry. Ms. Terhune's numerous articles on hedge funds and international tax matters have appeared in publications worldwide. Read Our Leading Media Content and Articles by Hannah Terhune on Hedge Funds and International Tax Planning, Chances are, if you have read anything related to starting a hedge fund, Ms. Terhune wrote it. Read Our Client Comments and Read About Hannah Terhune on LinkedIn. When you engage us you get a unique combination of securities, tax, and business experience. Give us the opportunity to use our knowledge and experience for you. No client is too large or too small for us. We pride ourselves in providing personal attention to each Client. We provide high quality services at competitive rates. But don't take our word for it, give us a call and let us prove what we can do for you.